<img height="1" width="1" style="display:none" src="https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=1575636522500575&amp;ev=PageView&amp;noscript=1">

Ken's Plumbing | Blog

Water Heater Replacement: Should I DIY or Call a Pro?

Posted by Ken Flournoy on Dec 27, 2024 11:50:07 AM

Water heater issues can be easy to overlook. Since water heaters are designed to last 15-20 years, they provide hot water on demand, and typically tucked away in garages or basements, homeowners often forget about them. And while not among the most common plumbing problems, water heaters can break down over time. Things like leaks and ruptures can cause damage to your home and plumbing system, and when you reach that point, it’s usually too late. 

The temptation to save money through DIY solutions is understandable, especially given the high costs of professional water heater repair or water heater replacement. However, messing around with water heaters involves complex and potentially dangerous elements, if mishandled.

Now, don’t get us wrong. We encourage a hands-on approach for minor fixes, and we love empowering homeowners to take charge of their plumbing. We even publish some content, like The Ultimate Guide to Frozen Pipe Repair or Fixing Plumbing Problems with Homemade Plumbing Repairs, to help ambitious homeowners get started. Yet, when replacing a water heater, the risks and technical complexities often outweigh the potential savings of a DIY approach.

 

Water Heater Replacement What Does the Job Entail?

Replacing a water heater is far more complicated than many homeowners realize. It’s not a simple plug-and-play home improvement project, but a complex task involving multiple technical and safety considerations. Here’s a breakdown of what this task entails and why it’s best to leave it to a professional plumber:

 

Addressing Safety Concerns

Water heaters are connected to exceptionally hot water, carbon monoxide, natural gas, electrical wiring, and pressure-controlled tanks. A single mistake during installation could result in catastrophic damage to your home or serious injury. Professional plumbers are trained to navigate these risks, ensuring safe and proper installation that protects your home and your family.

 

Technical Know-How

Installing a water heater isn’t as simple as screwing a few parts together. Your plumber will bring extensive knowledge of the piping, venting, and wiring involved in the process. They can handle tasks like:

  • Connecting the water heater to your home’s plumbing and electrical systems.
  • Assembling adapters and installing new pipe lengths.
  • Soldering fittings where needed.
  • Wiring the heater correctly, especially when switching from one type of unit to another (e.g., gas to electric water heater).

 

Specialized Equipment

Replacing a water heater requires a comprehensive toolbox that goes beyond basic home repair supplies. You’ll need specialty tools like soldering supplies, voltage testers, channel-lock pliers, and tubing cutters. Most homeowners don’t have these items readily available, making DIY replacement costly and challenging.

 

Regulatory Compliance

Installing a water heater also involves adhering to strict building and fire codes (only adding to the job’s complexity). A professional plumber will:

  • Ensure the installation meets local regulations.
  • Obtain any necessary permits for the work.
  • Guarantee the job is done correctly, safely, and legally.

 

Advantages of Hiring a Professional Plumber for Water Heater Replacement

In addition to addressing the complexities of water heater installation discreibed above, hiring a professional plumber offers some additional benefits. These extend to protection, peace of mind, and long-term value that DIY approaches simply cannot match.

To start, professional plumbers can offer warranty protection. When you DIY, you may save on upfront costs, but you're likely forfeiting the extra protection that comes with a professionally installed unit. Professional plumbers typically provide comprehensive warranties covering the installation and the water heater unit itself. This means you're covered if the system malfunctions or requires some future maintenance. 

Another primary consideration is time. Unlike what many assume, the average water heater replacement process requires three to four hours of dedicated work, and that's for a relatively straightforward swap of identical units. When the new system differs from the old one, the installation time can extend to a full day, and most homeowners simply don't have that amount of time to dedicate to a single home improvement project. Professional plumbers, by contrast, are committed to the task and can complete the job efficiently and effectively.

Finally, liability protection is perhaps the most critical advantage of professional water heater replacement. Water heater installation involves numerous inherent risks, from potential gas leaks to electrical complications that could compromise your home's safety. Licensed plumbers carry professional insurance that protects both themselves and you as the homeowner. If any mistakes occur during installation, the plumbing company assumes responsibility, not you. 

 

When Can You DIY a Water Heater Repair?

While some water heater issues require professional expertise, some minor maintenance tasks are well within the capabilities of a handy homeowner. These include, for instance, relighting the pilot light on gas heaters, adjusting the thermostat temperature, flushing the tank to remove sediment buildup, replacing the anode rod, and addressing minor valve leaks. 

Even if you can't handle these repairs yourself, staying vigilant can help you avoid costly water heater replacements. Especially with older systems, watch for signs of rust or leaks, as minor issues can quickly escalate if left unnoticed. Timely repairs are far less expensive and stressful than replacing the entire unit.

Still, it's crucial to approach any DIY water heater repair with caution and a clear understanding of your skill level. If you feel uncertain at any point, it's always best to consult a professional for some water heater services.

> Read more on How to Know Whether to DIY or Call a Plumber.

 

Professional Water Heater Services You Can Count On

Replacing a water heater is one area where professional expertise is often the safest and most efficient option. Attempting the job without the support of a skilled plumber can lead to costly mistakes, including failed repairs, fines for code violations, and, most importantly, potential risks to your safety.

At Ken’s Plumbing, we specialize in installing and replacing all types of water heaters, including gas, electric, tank, tankless, heat pump, and geothermal models. Our licensed plumbers have the skills, training, and equipment to ensure your water heater is installed safely, efficiently, and up to code.

Don’t take chances with your home’s safety or comfort, and let us help with professional and reliable water heater services. Call us at (864) 392-5470, contact us online, or schedule a service appointment to inspect your water heater. We’re looking forward to working with you.

Topics: Hiring a Plumber, Water Heaters